fill Latest Okanogan, Washington, weather fill
fill Omak-Okanogan County Chronicle, serving North Central Washington from Omak since 1910 Follow us on  twitter facebook fill
e-edition, read it today!
The Chronicle's
e-Edition
is our full print edition online ~ cover to cover!
You get access to both the Wednesday and Sunday newspapers for a regular subscription price of $30/year.
An ever-expanding database of past newspapers is fully searchable.
Check it out today!
Subscribe
Login

 
Ag Tab 2012
Ag Tab 2012

Infobook 2012
Infobook 2012

Oh Baby! 2011
Oh Baby! 2011

Winter Throwdown 2011
Winter Throwdown 2011

Best of 2011
Best of 2011

Snowmobiling Guide
Snowmobiling Guide 2011

Health and Medical Directory 2011
Health and Medical Directory 2011

Punt, Pass, Spike and Run 2011
Punt, Pass, Spike and Run 2011

Okanogan County Fair 2011
Okanogan County Fair 2011

Western Rendezvous
Western Rendezvous

Summer Fun, Safety, Coloring Book 2011 Summer Fun, Safety, Coloring Book

Graduation 2011 Graduation 2011

Fishrapper 2011 Fishrapper 2011

Vacationland 2011 Vacationland 2011

Play Ball 2011 Play Ball 2011

Sports

Past Sports Standings, Scores

Winter scores/standings

Blog Central

Okanogan County Transportation and Nutrition bus schedules

Class Reunions

Eagle Newspapers

Okanogan County website

Ferry County website

Elected Officials

Geology

Statewide traveler information

 
Posted: Tuesday, April 6, 2010 - 9:51 p.m. PDT
Murder trial gets underway with questioning of potential jurors
fill.gif (49 bytes)

Al Camp/The Chronicle

Attorneys for both the state at left and attorneys for defendants Tansy Fay-Arwen Mathis, fourth from left, and David Eugene Richards, far right, work their way through 102 jury questionnaires.

(Click on picture for bigger image)
fill.gif (49 bytes)
fill.gif (49 bytes)

Al Camp/The Chronicle

Questionnaires were gone over page by page, person by person by (from left) defense attorney Steve Graham, defendant Tansy Fay-Arwen Mathis, defense attorney Tony Frey and defendant David Eugene Richards.

(Click on picture for bigger image)
fill.gif (49 bytes)
fill.gif (49 bytes)

Al Camp/The Chronicle

County prosecutor Karl Sloan, left, and contract attorney Greg Weber go over a questionnaire.

(Click on picture for bigger image)
fill.gif (49 bytes)
fill.gif (49 bytes) Index to Michelle Kitterman murder stories
PAST STORIES:
April 23: Mathis found guilty on all counts; Richards guilty of murder and manslaughter
April 22: Jury begins deliberating in Kitterman murder trial  
April 21: Closing arguments expected April 22 in Kitterman murder trial
April 20: Defendant Mathis testifies about Kitterman death  
April 19: Pathologist testifies in murder trial about fetus age 
April 16: Testimony concludes for first week of Kitterman trial 
April 16: centers around defendants' and victim's relationship  
April 14: Witness describes defendant's telling of Kitterman's death 
April 13: Trial testimony centers on Hirst-Pavek's actions 
April 12: Phillips testifies, says he and Mathis stabbed Kitterman 
April 9: Attorneys give opening arguments, different versions of events leading to Kitterman's death  
April 8: Jury selected for murder trial 
April 7: Jury pool narrowed to 68 in second day of murder trial 
April 6: Murder trial gets underway with questioning of potential jurors  
March 30: Phillips pleads guilty in Kitterman death

Google Search of all stories at The Chronicle about Michelle Kitterman
fill.gif (49 bytes)
     By Al Camp
     The Chronicle

     OKANOGAN - The first day of the trial for two people accused of killing a Tonasket woman in March of last year wrapped up shortly after 5 p.m. Tuesday, April 6, following a day of interviewing potential witnesses and whittling down the remaining witness pool.
     Court personnel were calling 72 more people Tuesday night to appear in court in groups of 18 starting at 8:30 a.m. Wednesday, April 7.
     Jurors are being sought to hear the trial of "Tonasket" Tansy Fay-Arwen Mathis, 30, and David Eugene Richards, 34, both from Spokane.
     They are charged with aggravated first-degree murder or, in the alternative, first-degree murder with premeditation, first-degree manslaughter of an unborn child, tampering with evidence and first-degree kidnapping for the death of Michelle Kitterman.
     Kitterman was 25 and about 11 weeks pregnant when found dead March 1, 2009, on remote Stalder Road about 15 miles southwest of Tonasket.
     Brent "Hollywood" Lane Phillips, 29, also from Spokane, pleaded guilty March 29 to reduced charges of first-degree murder - premeditated murder, first-degree manslaughter of an unborn child, tampering with evidence and first-degree kidnapping.
     The state accepted Phillips' plea in exchange for his testimony in the trial.
     For Phillips, the state recommended a sentence of 26 years, which is about the middle of a sentencing range. Phillips is to be sentenced May 11, or four days after the latest date the trial is expected to last.
     A fourth defendant in the death of Kitterman, Lacey Kae Hirst-Pavek, 34, Crumbacher, is charged with first-degree murder and first-degree manslaughter. Hirst-Pavek allegedly hired Mathis to find people to rough up Kitterman and cause her to abort, court records said. She has a trial date of May 4.
     Hirst-Pavek's husband allegedly was the father of Kitterman's unborn child.
     On Tuesday, county prosecutor Karl Sloan and contract attorney Greg Weber represented the state.
     Steve Graham represented Mathis. Tony Frey and Sunshine Poliquin represented Richards.
     In open court until about 3 p.m., they individually questioned 50 potential jurors out of 152 that filled out questionnaires last Friday to help speed along the jury selection process.
     In the late afternoon, attorneys reduced the remaining 102 people to 72 to be called for questioning Wednesday. They will appear 18 at a time starting at 8:30 a.m., with two hours set to hear each group. Questioning of the final group will begin at 3 p.m.
     The attorneys are trying to find 16 jurors, which will include four unnamed alternates, to hear the case that on the questionnaire is estimated to last until possibly May 7.
     The 19-page questionnaire, prepared by Chelan County Superior Court Judge T.W. "Chip" Small, included the 19-page, 42-question juror questionnaire that was approved by all sides.
     Questions often cited in excusing jurors included if they knew law enforcement or potential witnesses, had strong views on immigration to the U.S., beliefs concerning judging another, vacation that coincided with the trial and physical handicaps or other hardships that would make it difficult to be a juror.
     The attorneys often came to a consensus on jurors who were excused, though the defense often asked to excuse people not initially proposed by the state.
     Mathis, who wore a flower print dress, took an active role in the selection process, looking at each person's questionnaire to assist Graham in possibly tossing some from the pool.
     Richards, dressed in a suit coat and tie, looked at the list far less.
     Neither was handcuffed while court was in session.
     Graham asked that after the jury was selected but prior to the trial starting that Small would rule concerning the state's witnesses allegedly testifying to conversations by Hirst-Pavek and Mathis.
     Graham took issue with a probable cause statement, saying Hirst-Pavek hired Mathis to find one or two people to kill Kitterman.
     "We contest all of that," said Graham, who said Hirst would be testifying indirectly by witnesses.
     The state agreed to not cover that area during voir dire or the questioning of potential jurors.
     Of those excused, reasons included:
     -One person said she prepared taxes at this time. Graham said he suspected she might be moonlighting and could not concentrate only on the trial.
     -Another said he was a starving artist and knew people involved. That caught Mathis' attention, and she checked out the questionnaire.
     -Another said the victim was his niece and he knew many of the witnesses.
     -On another tossed out for various reasons, Small said, "It's a good thing we're doing it one at a time with that on" concerning each question answered.
     Graham initially wanted to question one juror who, according to the questionnaire, had been sober only for a few months and suffered from depression. But it was pointed out the person also had a hearing problem. He allowed the person to be excused.
     -A 60-year-old juror was excused for having a pacemaker.
     -Some people were released and others not for saying their religious beliefs precluded them from making a judgment on another.
     -Someone who worked at a hospital was released due to hardship where she worked.
     -Also released was a man filling in for his supervisor to complete a federal contract by a deadline.
     -A student worried that she could not keep up with her studies if in trial.
     Those who were called for further questioning included:
     -Someone who was going to be on vacation during the trial.
     -One person who wrote, "I don't believe they would be in jail if they were innocent." Small asked defense attorneys if they wanted to call the person to give a legal education in public. The person was put in the list of possible callbacks.
     -One questionnaire was left blank except for a phone number and signature. One man had called to say he could not read or write English, Small said.
     "He said he'd do the best he could," said Small, who said despite his asking panels if anyone could not read or write English knew some embarrassed people would not admit to such.
     "This is a first for me," Graham said.
     "He does not need to read or understand English to be a U.S. citizen," said Small, who said English was the man's second language.
     Graham allowed that the man needed to appear on Wednesday, though he was going to research if a juror had to be able to read or understand English to be on a jury.
     -A 75-year-old woman said she'd planned a vacation during the trial. She was to appear Wednesday, perhaps to give her something to talk about during the trip, Small said.
     -Another called said that, in order to appear, the person would have to pay for a non-refundable motel to appear. The person was asked to show up to clarify why that was so.
     -One person expected to appear, though would be on crutches and could reschedule a physician's appointment.
     -Another called said he had a hearing assisted device.
     -Another was called despite writing the person had talked to Sloan in the past.
     Small asked Sloan if he remembered the conversation.
     "I do not remember," Sloan said with a chuckle.
     -Another asked to appear to show extreme hardship after writing the person had a non-refundable plane ticket.
     -Discussion also included that some jurors could stand in the back of the jury box to stretch.
     Small reminded attorneys that they might not being so willing to call so many to appear if they were still questioning jurors Wednesday evening.
 
  NEWS HEADLINES
Three injured in truck-school bus crash 
District 6 begins 1A boys and girls hoop tournaments
Council OKs garbage rate increase
Quincy, Brewster set to join Caribou Trail League
Feb. 4 fundraiser benefits Conscious Culture Festival
Twisp skier wins Apple Cup crown
Seedings done; Super sub-regionals planned for Lake Roosevelt
Seedings done; District 6 wrestling comes to Omak
Teen arrested for vehicle break-ins
Winter weather advisory issued for Okanogan, Ferry counties
Girls basketball: Brewster swats Oroville
Boys basketball: Chelan edges Tonasket
Wrestling: Liberty Bell finishes second at Kittitas
Earthquake rocks area south of Penticton
Witnesses to fatal crash are sought
Poetry Out Loud is tonight in Okanogan
Chelan woman dies in two-vehicle crash
Ecstasy, cash seized west of Danville
Four quakes reported in the past two weeks
State plans Okanogan meeting to discuss elk plan
Motorists arrested in drunken driving campaign
Russian artists’ works displayed at Dry Falls
Morton asks governor to rescind board appointment
Discover Pass expansion gets Senate committee nod
 
  RECENTLY POSTED PHOTO ALBUMS
Dec. 17: Omak boys vs. Bridgeport - Raider Holiday Tournament
Dec. 17: Lake Roosevelt girls vs. Bridgeport - Raider Holiday Tournament
Dec. 16: Cashmere at Brewster girls basketball
Dec. 10: Wrestling at Okanogan
Dec. 10: Pateros at Tonasket girls basketball
Dec. 10: Pateros at Tonasket boys basketball
Dec. 6: Brewster at Okanogan girls basketball
Dec. 6: Brewster at Okanogan boys basketball
Dec. 3: Omak PIT wrestling tournament
Dec. 3: Oroville at Tonasket boys basketball
Dec. 3: Oroville at Tonasket girls basketball
Dec. 1: Bridgeport at Omak girls basketball
Dec. 1: Bridgeport at Omak boys basketball
Nov. 26: Christmas at the End of the Road
Nov. 12: Brewsteer at La Conner state soccer
Nov. 4: Lakeside at Tonasket post-season football
Nov. 1: Soap Lake at Brewster state 2B football
Nov. 1: Tiebreaker football at Bridgeport
Nov. 1: Omak at Okanogan playoff soccer
Oct. 29: Liberty Bell vs. Bridgeport soccer playin
 

newspaper for ad Get all your Okanogan County news and sports coverage delivered to you for as little as 58 cents a week.
 Legal Considerations
The Chronicle respects your right to privacy. Please read our privacy policy for details concerning our use of customer information.

Owned and operated by Eagle Newspapers Inc., unless otherwise noted. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed without permission.

fill fill fill Sunrise Chevrolet
Auto Fresh
Red Cross
Edward Jones
Visit Fogle Pump and Supply
Visit John L. Scott Realty
Visit Remax Lake and Country
Visit the Breadline Cafe in Omak, Washington
Cramer's Furniture Online Funnies
MyCapture photo buying online
 
Chronicles of the Okanogan
A history of the Okanogan Valley as published in the pages of The Chronicle.
A century ago, The Chronicle was founded, in part, as a voice for the residents and community of unincorporated Omak.
This 100-page, large-format book presents a unique look at the history of the area as told by the newspaper's publishers, editors and reporters.